6.A CRITICAL PERSPECTIVE ON ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
A CRITICAL DISCUSSION:
Organisational culture shapes the behaviours of the leaders describes corporate culture as the ‘soft part’ of an organisation that is immediately noticeable by people as they come in contact with the organisation, employee and it can be “visible and feel-able,”
Organisational culture laid a playground for instituting ‘attitudinal’ and ‘behavioural’ standards for the entire organisation, which gives guidelines to the organisation’s staff (Mehta & Maheshwari, 2015). Rashid et al. (2003) emphasised that organisational culture is integral in the corporate change process and shapes employees’ attitudes towards organisational change.
There is already extensive research that argues that integrated corporate culture that foster 'involvement' 'consistency' 'adaptability' and 'clarity of mission ' diminish resistance to change and enhance employee continued commitment to organisational change (Janicijevic, 2012, Lok and Crawford, 2000, Parent &Lovelace, 2018, Harris & Ogbonna 2002, Mehta & Maheshwari, 2015, Chiloane-Tsoka, 2013, Rashid et al. 2003, and Islam, 2013).
French & Holden (2012) advance that positive organisational culture mitigates the ill consequence of grapevine during an organisational change. In his work, Harwiki (2016) notes that the corporate culture formats employees to quickly adapt to the organisational environment, putting on acceptable behaviour in executing their jobs following the organisation’s values.
To achieve successful organisational change, managers must create alignment between change strategies and culture (Kezar & Eckel, 2002, Rashid, Sambasivan & Abdul Rahman, 2003).
Attitude is tough to change; this is because of the tendency of inherency of resistance. Leaders can formulate appropriate changes strategies and effectively manage change processes. The employee perception of the change and the leader's ability to engage and create an inclusive environment will determine their response. It emphasise that an organisational change that requires significant changes in the conventional behaviour, power, structure, and culture tends to face stiffer resistance from an employee.
Since individual employees tend to respond to organisational change in different ways (Smith et al., 2012), managers should evaluate both positive and negative effects of change on employee adaptability and stimulate a positive and participative work environment (Parent & Lovelace, 2018).
Large-scale organisational change, whether in the form of mergers, acquisitions, restructuring, or downsizing, is a widespread feature of today’s ever-changing work environment (Parent &Lovelace, 2018:212). So, given the organisational dilemma, firms must gain optimal employee support to adjust to these ‘new features and abilities. It is these supports during the change process in the form of training, planning, and engagement that will shape employee behaviour and increase adaptability to organisational change.
Due to continuous change in the global business landscape, agree that organisations should grasp and implement a corporate culture that is receptive to change; despite being enormous to attain.
Shared values and beliefs of employees constitute more incredible influencers of employee behaviour. Thus, changes in corporate strategies without congruent organisational behaviour, values, and belief could lead to change failure (Struwig & Smith, 2002) and stress and dissatisfaction with proposed change.
As leaders create a shared vision and stimulate actions to achieve the organisation’s goal, effective leadership remains crucial for implementing organisational change. Managers' behaviour and attitude towards employees affect social and psychological interactions. For instance, a survey conducted on 200 university teachers indicates that leadership and organisational culture directly impact the employees’ affective commitment to change (Yaseen, Ali & Asrar-ul-Haq, 2018). Its consistency induces employee inclination to an organisation and increases their commitment to organisational change.
The relationship between change and organisational culture in the present-day business climate is that, as Lewis et al. (2001) describe, while change is a determinant of corporate growth, sustainability and competitiveness, organisational culture stimulates employee response towards organisational change.
Organizational Culture on attitudes towards Organisational change', Leadership & Organizational Development Journal, 25(2), pp. 161-179.
Adrian, C. (2002) ‘Organizational Culture: Organizational Change’? Journal of Organizational Change Management, 15(4), pp. 425-432.
Al-Ali, A. A., et al. (2017) ‘Change management through leadership: the mediating role of organisational culture’, International Journal of Organizational Analysis, 25(4), pp. 723-739. DOI 10.1108/IJOA-01-2017-111.
Chiloane-Tsoka, E. (2013) ‘The influence of corporate culture on organisational change of first national bank of Namibia’, International Journal of Business and Economic Development, 1(3), pp. 15-24.


Your discussion effectively emphasizes how organizational culture shapes leaders' behavior and impacts employee attitudes toward change. The importance of positive culture in managing change challenges is well highlighted. The brief mention of leadership's role and the complexities of large scale change adds depth. Nicely done!
ReplyDeleteThank you for your thoughtful feedback! I'm pleased to hear that the discussion on how organizational culture influences leaders' behavior and employee attitudes towards change resonated with you. The recognition of the significance of a positive culture in navigating change challenges is indeed crucial. Additionally, acknowledging the complexities of leadership in large-scale change situations adds depth to the understanding of the topic. If you have any more insights to share or questions to discuss, feel free to continue the conversation!
DeleteVery insightful reading! Regarding mentioned large-scale organizational changes from acquisitions & mergers can be observable from Moden day organizations. Some cultural mergers in organizations cultures are contradicting to each other and still they merged successfully. One of the classical examples that we can evaluate is Walmart & Jet.com merger. Walmart is a retailed giant where they preferred physical sales whereas Jet.com into e-commerce and online sales. Refer below extract which indicates how two cultures embrace each other's.
ReplyDelete“We’re thrilled to welcome the Jet.com team to the Walmart family and excited to expand the ways we serve our current customers and reach new customers online,” McMillon said. “Jet brings a unique approach and technology that puts customers in control of their experience, helping them find additional ways to save.”
(Reference: 19th Sep 2016)
Reference
“Walmart Completes Acquisition of Jet.Com, Inc..” Walmart Corporate News and Information, 19 Sept. 2016, corporate.walmart.com/news/2016/09/19/walmart-completes-acquisition-of-jet-com-inc.
The Walmart and Jet.com merger indeed serves as a fascinating case study of successful cultural integration despite apparent contradictions. This strategic move highlights the adaptability and flexibility that organizations must embrace during large-scale changes, such as mergers and acquisitions.
DeleteWalmart, traditionally a retail giant with a focus on physical sales, recognized the need to expand its presence in the rapidly growing e-commerce market. Jet.com, on the other hand, was an e-commerce platform with innovative technology and a customer-centric approach. Despite the cultural differences in their business models, Walmart welcomed the Jet.com team with enthusiasm, emphasizing the unique strengths each entity brought to the table.
This successful integration reflects a willingness to learn and adapt from both sides. Walmart's statement, as mentioned in your extract, showcases the recognition of Jet.com's unique approach and technology that empowers customers. This acknowledgment of strengths and a commitment to serving customers better have likely played a crucial role in the success of the merger.
In the ever-evolving business landscape, organizations must be agile and open to change. The ability to integrate diverse cultures and leverage the strengths of each entity is a hallmark of successful mergers. The Walmart and Jet.com case exemplifies how strategic alignment and a shared commitment to customer satisfaction can bridge cultural gaps and lead to a successful integration.
Reference:
"Walmart Completes Acquisition of Jet.Com, Inc." Walmart Corporate News and Information, 19 Sept. 2016, corporate.walmart.com/news/2016/09/19/walmart-completes-acquisition-of-jet-com-inc.